Contact

Trademarks

Is My Trademark Too Similar? Likelihood of Confusion in the Philippines (with Supreme Court Cases)

Direct answer: A Philippine trademark is "too similar" when it's likely to cause confusion with an earlier mark for identical or related goods or services. IPOPHL must refuse a mark that "nearly resembles" an earlier mark "as to be likely to deceive or cause confusion" (IP Code, Sec. 123.1(d)). The Supreme Court uses two tests. The dominancy test focuses on the main, eye-catching or ear-catching feature of the marks. The holistic (totality) test compares the marks as a whole, including labels and packaging (McDonald's Corp. v. L.C. Big Mak Burger, Inc., G.R. No. 143993, 18 Aug. 2004). The same or a similar name can sometimes coexist on unrelated products, even within the same Nice class (Taiwan Kolin Corp. v. Kolin Electronics Co., G.R. No. 209843, 25 Mar. 2015).

"Is my brand name too close to theirs?" is the question behind most trademark refusals, oppositions and demand letters in the Philippines. This guide explains how IPOPHL and the courts decide, using real Supreme Court cases, and gives you a practical self-check before you file.

What the law says

The IP Code bars registration of a mark that is (Sec. 123.1(d)):

"identical with a registered mark belonging to a different proprietor or a mark with an earlier filing or priority date, in respect of: (i) The same goods or services, or (ii) Closely related goods or services, or (iii) If it nearly resembles such a mark as to be likely to deceive or cause confusion."

For infringement, the owner of a registered mark can stop others from using "identical or similar signs" for "identical or similar" goods or services where there's a likelihood of confusion. "In case of the use of an identical sign for identical goods or services, a likelihood of confusion shall be presumed" (Sec. 147.1). Copying "a dominant feature" of a registered mark can be infringement (Sec. 155).

So two questions always matter:

  1. How similar are the marks? (sight, sound, meaning, overall impression)
  2. How related are the goods or services?

The two tests the Supreme Court uses

Dominancy test Holistic (totality) test
Focus "the similarity of the prevalent or dominant features of the competing trademarks" "the entirety of the marks as applied to the products, including the labels and packaging"
Weight given to "the aural and visual impressions created by the marks," with "little weight to factors like prices, quality, sales outlets, and market segments" All features on both labels, not just the predominant words
Source Skechers, U.S.A., Inc. v. Inter Pacific Industrial Trading Corp., G.R. No. 164321, 23 Mar. 2011 Same

In Skechers, the Court also noted that under the dominancy test, "[d]uplication or imitation is not necessary; neither is it required that the mark sought to be registered suggests an effort to imitate."

Real cases, explained simply

Big Mac vs Big Mak (2004): sound and spelling

In McDonald's v. L.C. Big Mak Burger, the Court applied the dominancy test and found "Big Mak" confusingly similar to "Big Mac" for hamburgers. Its reasoning: "aurally the two marks are the same," and since "in Filipino, the letter 'k' replaces 'c' in spelling," even the last letters match. The Court held the respondent liable for trademark infringement and unfair competition (G.R. No. 143993).

Lesson: changing a letter, especially a "c" to a "k," doesn't avoid confusion if the name sounds the same.

Master Roast vs Flavor Master (2001): the dominant word

In Societe des Produits Nestle v. Court of Appeals, the Court agreed with the trademark office that "the word MASTER is the dominant feature" of Nestlé's coffee marks. It noted that MASTER was printed in bold letters "almost twice the size" of the word ROAST, and, citing the Court of Appeals' own words, that ordinary buyers of "common and less expensive household products like coffee" are "undiscerningly rash" in buying them. The Court reinstated the trademark office's decision against registration of FLAVOR MASTER (G.R. No. 112012, 4 Apr. 2001).

Lesson: adding a word in front of someone else's dominant word may not be enough, especially for cheap, everyday goods.

The Skechers "S" (2011): a logo's dominant feature

In Skechers, the respondent sold "Strong" rubber shoes bearing a stylized "S." The Court held that the stylized "S" was the dominant feature of Skechers' registered "S"-within-an-oval mark, "as it is precisely the stylized 'S' which catches the eye of the purchaser." Using it without the oval "already constitutes infringement under the Dominancy Test." The Court added: "The most successful form of copying is to employ enough points of similarity to confuse the public, with enough points of difference to confuse the courts" (G.R. No. 164321).

Lesson: a different brand name won't save a logo that copies the other mark's key design element.

GALLO wine vs GALLO cigarettes (2004): unrelated goods

In Mighty Corp. v. E. & J. Gallo Winery, the same word GALLO was used for wine and for cigarettes. The Court found "wines and cigarettes are not identical or competing products," noting they fell in different classes but stressing that "product classification alone cannot serve as the decisive factor." It held that "the mere fact that one person has adopted and used a particular trademark for his goods does not prevent the adoption and use of the same trademark by others on articles of a different description." The cigarette makers were not liable for infringement or unfair competition (G.R. No. 154342, 14 July 2004).

Lesson: identical names can coexist when the goods are truly unrelated. Note that this case predates many later rulings, and well-known marks get broader protection (IP Code, Sec. 123.1(e)–(f)).

KOLIN vs KOLIN (2015): same class, different products

In Taiwan Kolin v. Kolin Electronics, Kolin Electronics had registered KOLIN for goods such as automatic voltage regulators, converters, rechargers and power supplies in Class 9. Taiwan Kolin applied for KOLIN for television sets and DVD players, also in Class 9. Under the heading "Identical marks may be registered for products from the same classification," the Court allowed Taiwan Kolin's application. It held that the registration "not only covers unrelated good[s], but is also incapable of deceiving the ordinary intelligent buyer" (G.R. No. 209843).

Lesson: being in the same Nice class doesn't automatically mean the goods are related. What matters is the nature of the products, how they're sold, and who buys them.

Two kinds of confusion

The Supreme Court recognizes (Skechers):

  • Confusion of goods (product confusion): a buyer purchases one product thinking it's the other.
  • Confusion of business (source confusion): the goods differ, but buyers would assume they come from the same company, or that the companies are connected.

That's why a café named after a famous fast-food chain can be a problem even if it sells different food.

Kahit iba ang spelling, kung pareho ang tunog at pareho ang produkto, puwedeng ma-reject o makasuhan.

A self-check before you file

Question Higher risk if...
Does the main word or design look or sound like an existing mark? Yes, even with different spelling (e.g., c/k, s/z)
Are the goods or services the same or related? Same products, complementary products, or sold in the same stores
Is the earlier mark famous? Yes. Well-known marks are protected even for some unrelated goods
Are the products cheap, everyday purchases? Yes. Buyers pay less attention
Did you add only a generic or descriptive word? Yes, e.g., "Master Roast" vs "Flavor Master"
Does your logo reuse the other mark's key design element? Yes, even with a different name

Example: a start-up wants to sell milk tea as CHA-KAYA (made up). The search shows an existing CHAKAYA for restaurant services. The names sound identical, and drinks and restaurant services are closely related, so the risk is high. The founders switch to a coined name, TSALORA (also made up), before printing cups.

How to search properly

  1. Search IPOPHL's trademark database on WIPO Publish and the WIPO Global Brand Database.
  2. Search sound-alikes, misspellings, translations and the dominant word on its own.
  3. Check related classes, not only your own. See trademark classes.

Our step-by-step trademark search guide walks through it.

If IPOPHL or another owner says your mark is too similar

Frequently asked questions

How does IPOPHL decide if two trademarks are confusingly similar?

It looks at how similar the marks are in sight, sound and meaning, and how related the goods or services are. Philippine courts use the dominancy test, which focuses on dominant features, and the holistic test, which looks at the marks as a whole.

What is the dominancy test in Philippine trademark law?

A test that focuses on the similarity of the prevalent or dominant features of competing marks. It gives more weight to the aural and visual impressions on buyers than to price, quality or sales outlets.

Can two businesses use the same trademark in the Philippines?

Sometimes, if their goods or services are unrelated and buyers wouldn't be confused. The Supreme Court allowed GALLO on both wine and cigarettes, and KOLIN on both voltage regulators and televisions.

If my brand is spelled differently, is it safe?

Not necessarily. In the Big Mak case, the Court found "Big Mak" confusingly similar to "Big Mac" because the two sound the same.

Does being in a different Nice class mean no conflict?

No. Classification alone isn't decisive. Related goods in different classes can conflict, and unrelated goods in the same class may not.

Is a logo with a different name safe if the design looks similar?

Not if it copies the dominant feature. In Skechers, a stylized "S" on another brand's shoes was infringement even without the oval.

What should I do if my mark is too close to an existing one?

Change it before you invest in branding, or get professional advice on whether narrowing your goods or other arguments could work.

Talk to Recurra

Not sure if your brand is too close to an existing mark? Book a free consultation with Recurra. We'll search the IPOPHL register, assess the confusion risk and recommend whether to file, adjust or rebrand. Recurra's fee is quoted after the consultation. See our Trademark Registration page.